Identifying potential clients approaching their 65th birthday is a critical component for any successful Medicare Advantage marketing strategy. The challenge lies not only in generating a steady stream of these ‘turning 65’ leads but also in clearly communicating the benefits of your product, which may not be immediately apparent to them.
THE CHALLENGE
Developing a Successful Strategy in America’s Competitive Medicare Market
In the toughest Medicare market in the U.S., we aimed to craft a marketing strategy that would help our client get noticed for their Medicare Advantage plans.
NextPage and its partners excelled in handling monthly mailings in 2021 and 2022, exceeding expectations. However, in 2023, a change in strategy led to less favorable results.
Recognizing the need for expert guidance, the client’s VP of Marketing reverted to NextPage’s proven strategy in 2024. This shift resulted in a remarkable 121% improvement in key performance indicators (KPIs).
THE SOLUTION
Data-Driven, Multi-Channel, Medicare Direct Marketing
We implemented a comprehensive solution leveraging various marketing tactics and data-driven strategies to effectively target potential Medicare Advantage customers. The key components of the solution included:
List Acquisition and Modeling
- Using list strategies like age-in, custom modeling, and adding demographic, psychographic, and cluster analysis data to craft highly targeted mailing lists.
- Utilizing a scorecard approach to prioritize leads based on their propensity to respond and convert.
Multichannel Marketing Approach
- Using a combination of Medicare direct mail, social media, TV, and print advertising to engage the target audience across multiple touchpoints.
- 87% YoY increase in leads attributed to the marketing strategy.
- Direct mail continued to dominate as a key tool for generating leads.
- Direct Mail leads alone increased 217% YoY.
THE SOLUTION (continued)
Tactical Partnerships and Value-Added Services
- Collaborating with partners to discuss and implement tactical strategies.
- IP targeting, shape-cut envelopes, and enhanced informed delivery helped to increase the effectiveness of direct mail campaigns.
- Leveraging USPS promotions of 2-4% to achieve postal discounts, resulting in substantial cost savings of nearly $12,000.
Data-Driven Targeting and Optimization
- A two-step approach was used to help qualify leads for the sales team: age-in direct mail campaigns and educational seminars for people nearing age 65 (Medicare eligible).
- Acquiring data from multiple sources and leveraging waterfall data techniques to ensure comprehensive coverage across targeted markets.
- Utilizing look-alike modeling and affinity scoring to identify and prioritize prospects with the highest propensity to respond.
- Optimizing targeting strategies based on performance data and client feedback.
THE RETURN
Achieving Exceptional Results and Cost Savings in a Competitive Landscape
By implementing this comprehensive solution, NextPage helped the client achieve successful results in acquiring new Medicare Advantage members across the highly competitive market. Key outcomes included:
- Exceeding client-provided response rate projections in both 2021 and 2022.
- Regaining control over the marketing strategy in 2024, leading to results that met or exceeded previous performance levels ( 178%).
- Effectively targeting and engaging potential Medicare Advantage customers through data-driven, multichannel marketing efforts.
- Total leads increased YoY 31%.
- Achieving cost savings through postal discounts and optimized targeting strategies.
Specializing in data-driven marketing for “Age-In Direct Mail” and “Medicare Advantage Marketing,” NextPage’s expertise in direct mail campaigns and value-added services helps them succeed in the competitive Medicare Advantage market. These strategies have been crucial in successfully acquiring new members.
Trying to generate Medicare leads requires strict adherence to the guidelines from the Medicare Communications and Marketing Guidelines. NextPage has the expertise you need to generate quality Medicare leads.
IP Targeting Direct Mail Healthcare Industry
8300 NE Underground Drive, Pillar 122 | Kansas City, Missouri 64161
816.459.8404 local | 816.459.8407 fax
800.660.0108 | goNextPage.com
REV 08092024